Closed-trade vs. open-trade drawdown
Posted: Thu Oct 30, 2003 6:38 am
Hi traders and researchers,
Which drawdown figure do you prefer to use when evaluating a trading system: closed-trade or open-trade drawdown? For systems trading multiple markets I prefer open-trade DD calculated every day on the close. I found that closed-trade DD often distorts the reality. For example, if you have several open positions and close one of them at a big loss, your closed-trade DD drops even though your equity may have actually risen since the liquidation of the previous position due to big profits on other open positions. Also, I remember doing a simulation in Excel which showed that for a particular equity curve I was analysing the max open-trade DD was lower that max closed-trade DD (due to the effect I described above), although all books and sites that I read said it should be the other way round.
Tomasz
Which drawdown figure do you prefer to use when evaluating a trading system: closed-trade or open-trade drawdown? For systems trading multiple markets I prefer open-trade DD calculated every day on the close. I found that closed-trade DD often distorts the reality. For example, if you have several open positions and close one of them at a big loss, your closed-trade DD drops even though your equity may have actually risen since the liquidation of the previous position due to big profits on other open positions. Also, I remember doing a simulation in Excel which showed that for a particular equity curve I was analysing the max open-trade DD was lower that max closed-trade DD (due to the effect I described above), although all books and sites that I read said it should be the other way round.
Tomasz